Monday 8 October 2012

Eurozone reform and austerity is a policy disaster – Amartya Sen

Picture source: The Guardian

Amartya Sen, Nobel Memorial Prize Laureate and Professor of Economics and Philosophy at Harvard University has described the binding together of reform and austerity as a solution to the Eurozone crisis as not only intellectually confused but also a policy disaster. This was disclosed when he delivered the academic opening year lecture of Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies entitled “What’s the use of Economics?” in Geneva October 3, 2012.

Prof. Sen stated that the current strategy being imposed on European countries in financial difficulties is not going to resolve the crisis. “The Euro crisis is not going to be resolved by merely bailing out countries in financial difficulties”, he said adding that “it is difficult to see how austerity can be a soundly reason in economic solution to the European malaise today”. He expressed doubts whether austerity will steer economies plunged in excessive public debts out of their immediate problems. Prof. Sen advised austerity is not the effective way of reducing public deficit. “It may not be plausible way of reducing public deficit at all”, he stated adding that "for the fact that it [austerity] hasn't led to that [reducing public deficit] should not come as a surprise."

Making an exposition on the financial crisis that has bedeviled European countries especially Spain, Greece and Portugal, he argued that the implementation of austerity along with reform has undermined the impacts of real reform. “One of the worst aspects of the policy of austerity being comprehensibly imposed along with reform has been undermining the feasibility of real reform”, Prof. Sen asserted while explaining that “this has confounded two distinct agendas: reforms of bad administrative arrangements such as people evading taxes, of government serving using favouratism and for that matter preserving unviable conventions about retiring age; and austerity in a form of ruthless cuts on public services and social securities”. He advised there should be a clear distinction between reforms of bad administrative arrangements and cuts in public services though the requirements for a financial discipline have tendered to amalgamate the two.

Professor Amartya Sen warned leaders of European countries of the significant impact of austerity to outside borders. He said the impacts of austerity are not felt only within the borders of one country but in other countries through international trade and exchange. He stated that “austerity is an odd way of trying to cut down deficit” indicating again that “one country’s austerity is a dampener for the economic outcome expenses of other countries as well”. He advised that a good trading system could function alongside providing the necessary public services.

Meanwhile, The Guardian [www.guardian.co.uk] reports on Thursday October 4 that Institute of International Finance (IIF), an influential group of international banks and insurers, has attacked political leaders in Europe over their handling of the Greek crisis, arguing that the singleminded pursuit of austerity has made the situation worse. The Chairman of IIF, Charles Dallara in highlighting the associated challenges of austerity is quoted as saying "The world economy appears to be stuck at the crossroads, being pushed in one direction by easier monetary policy, and pulled in another by fiscal austerity". "The international financial community has a collective interest in reducing the uncertainty that currently surrounds the global economic outlook. If we want to lay the basis for a durable global economic expansion, then we need to see more concerted action by the world's policymakers", said Mr. Dallara.

As part of efforts to curtailing the persistent crisis, Eurozone finance ministers will meet in Luxembourg on Monday October 8 for the inaugural meeting of the Board of Governors of the European Stability Mechanism (ESM), bound to replace the European Financial Stability Facility as the Eurozone’s permanent bail-out fund. German Chancellor Angela Merkel will also visit Greece for the first time since the Eurozone debt crisis erupted this week widely seen as a show of support for Athens.

Story by: Stephen Yeboah, in Geneva, Switzerland [profstephenyeboah@gmail.com]

No comments:

Post a Comment